Avoiding the Mentality of Hiring “Rock Stars”

There’s this sub-culture in startup-land where everything revolves around hiring and retaining “rock star” engineers. And I think it’s mortifying. Not the idea itself, but the implications.

I have heard it over and over from people I respect. But there’s a subtle insinuation that the blame of poor execution rests on whether or not somebody is a “rock star.”

Let’s flip the focus around: what is the difference between a good and bad manager? It’s simple:

  1. Good managers make everybody better. Bad managers don’t help anybody, but hopefully don’t make anybody perform worse.
  2. Blaming somebody for not being a “rock star” is an easy way to shift the blame from yourself.
  3. If managing “rock stars” and firing “non-rock stars” is what management boiled down to, managers wouldn’t be needed.

Hiring a Kobe Bryant for your basketball team is a good idea. But it’s preposterous to blame a losing record on the lack of a 5-man Kobe team.

History is full of leaders pulling off great feats with an unknown team of rookies. Be that leader. Elevate the team. The role of a manager is to help people produce their best work — “rock stars” or not. And, if anything, great leaders forge the rock stars everybody ends up talking about.

“Michi’s Minions” – On Respecting Co-workers

Relatively early in my career, I’ve heard the phrase “Michi’s minions” a number of times. People use it to jokingly refer to my team. They say it in private, so I think some people might conclude it’s just a crass joke. Perhaps. For people that know my crude sense of humor, my offense to this joke probably takes you by surprise. Every time I hear that phrase, I immediately conclude the other person is not somebody I want to work for.

To me, it indicates a condescending attitude that the person has toward employees. I once heard the analogy that management is like a rowing team. You’re the coxswain that helps keep the rowboat straight. Yet, when you think about it, you don’t lift a finger to help the results get done. If somebody gets tired or wants to quit, you can’t take out a whip and start cracking. At the same time, without the coxswain, the team will never make it to the finish line. You both need each other. All of my greatest accomplishments as a leader in an organization were because of the hard work the team put in. To forget that your staff were the ones furiously rowing is ignorant if not insulting.

When somebody thinks that “managing” equates to “having minions,” it’s not pretty to watch them get a little power. I’ve seen this a few times now and it had disturbing results every time. The usual trend is:

  1. They give their staff all the boring, dirty work
  2. They scold in public and praise in private (if at all)
  3. They say, “I don’t need to be liked as long as work is getting done”
  4. People start quitting

I want to address #3 really quickly. “Being liked” and “getting things done” are not mutually exclusive. A good leader will get both done together, every time. If you can’t create a work environment where people are happy, you aren’t qualified to be a leader. Think about the last job where you constantly went above and beyond. Did you like your boss? I bet you did. I am very confident in the importance of having a good relationship with those you work with.

This post isn’t about watching your language. It’s about watching your attitude.

You need your team more than they need you.